I have been using this eyeliner, along with many other, and can now say with confidence, that this is by far, the eyeliner you need to add to your makeup kit! It is incredibly effective, bold and gives you a nice clean line, especially for cat eyes! Application is super easy , as it is a pen and the tip is fine, so it allows for precision. The product itself, lasts for a very long time and it is definitely worth the price! I would recommend this to all makeup lovers, if you're looking for a quality make-up pen, this is the one!! THE ONE!

Love this product. The only eyeliner i use.
Glides easy. Super fine or for winged liner, Perfect
Wont consider any other liner

I have tried MANY liquid liners and this is the one I have gone back to again and again!
The tip of the pen is super fine and allows you to choose to draw on a very fine line or you can make it as thick as you please as well. Also, the fact that it is in a pen (almost like a felt tip) makes application easier than having to paint it on with a brush - it gives you a steadier hand and therefore a much more clean and neat line. It lasts all day (or night) long, but is still easy to remove with a good eye makeup remover so you won't end up looking like a panda once you've wiped it off. Definitely a favorite for me!

I bought this overseas in a set of the full size black, and the travel sized blue, green and brown.

I have deep set eyes with hooded lids so I always end up with my winged liner transferring onto my top lid or smudging all over my lid. With the Stila liner I can apply a winged line and have it last almost the ENTIRE day. If you have eyes that are more wide set with a fuller lid space, you will fall in LOVE with this eyeliner. It is best for thin or thick cat liner or whatever shape you like on the top lid but not grand for waterline or tight lining.

I had to try it because of this review and I'm glad I did. Slightly on the pricey side but well worth the penny. A waterproof liquid eyeliner that actually is waterproof is refreshing... Stila stays all day!!!

As someone who cannot go a day without eyeliner , I have tried a lot of brands in my search for perfection and I can really say that this baby is it!

The fact that it is exactly like a marker with a fine tip, makes application a breeze and the formula is amazing, lasts until you decide to remove it, which I might add takes some effort but that's not something that worries me considering the awesomeness of this liner.

Waterproof, lasts all day, application is so easy with the nifty felt pen tip ... What more could I ask for ? Well I could ask that it be a little less expensive lol .. All in all a fabulous buy!

This is mainly saved for special occasions because of the high price tag, but that is the only negative. It is rare to find a product that really does what it says but in this case the liner clings to your skin until you are ready to remove it. This takes a bit of work and makeup removal products but at least I know the liner will not make a move until I decide it is time to go.

I like this because it's basically like using a khoki (felt tip marker) to draw on your face :D I'm not the most precise when it comes to applying makeup but this makes it way easier. It also lasts quite a while, and I haven't noticed any smudging - which is huge for me as I have super oily eyelids that melt everything that comes near it. One issue I have is that the tip sometimes starts to get... straggly (not sure if that's the right word) So what I do is just cut a small part of the tip off to make it sharp again. It IS quite pricey but the lasting results make it worth it.

I am still new to liquid eye liners, never really liked them as I found it really difficult to apply and it's time consuming. Last year a friend applied it on my eyes and I loved how it looked. So I bought this eye liner in Black and I can truly say that I'm really happy with it. It lasts for hours and does not easily smudge once dry. Tip: Keep it upside down to keep, advice given to me by the sales consultant.

Albeit a bit pricey I bought mine in the cute retrochic collectors tin,a collection of 5 awesome does what it claims eyeliners in: Emerald green, Navy blue, Stingray black, Aubergine burgundy and Lionfish bronze hues.I haven't looked back!after a hot humid day in Durban when I get home with my make up having sweated off the one feature on my face still neat and still tidy is my eyes!eyeliner neatly in place as if freshly applied!You would not go wrong with this one!

I purchased mine in Intense Black, and I agree with the other reviewers. The formula is HIGHLY PIGMENTED, giving off that deep intense black!Q The tip makes for easy and precise application which is essential when doing the classic pin up girl eye look. I find that I can achieve this hassle free with this product. It stays on all day, is water/sweat proof, even with my oily eye lids, it did not budge! So really impressed. For R200 though, it is a bit steep, so will most likely not re purchase. I was curious about this and found it at a steal. I would ultimately prefer a wind up crayon as apposed to liquid liner.

I think Zahraa has said almost everything I wanted to say about this. The packaging is to the point. The cap closes really well. It actually makes a weird click and jump when you close it, which freaks me out a bit but you know your product won't dry out because it seals so tightly.
The color I have is "Intense Black" and its exactly that. The color is pitch black and incredibly pigmented. The liner has a sharp point and glides on daily. You do not need to take breaks. The color comes out fluidly. I wore it all day and it stayed on with out smudging!
It is quite pricey at R190 and I am not too sure if I would purchase it because of the price. The fact that I am guaranteed a good product though would make me consider buying it.

Once again, Stila has outdone themselves.

All i wanna say about this product is YES YES YES!!

This product is amazing It has a super sharp top for very precise lines and it isn't too flimsy so you get the exact result you want.

The color is very pigmented and doesn't come out grey like alot of other pen liners i've tried. It's waterproof and really does stay all day.

This is a definite must for anyone looking for a good pen liquid liner.