I am still new to liquid eye liners, never really liked them as I found it really difficult to apply and it's time consuming. Last year a friend applied it on my eyes and I loved how it looked. So I bought this eye liner in Black and I can truly say that I'm really happy with it. It lasts for hours and does not easily smudge once dry. Tip: Keep it upside down to keep, advice given to me by the sales consultant.