I bought the colour outside the line collection tin with 5 great waterproof, soft, retractable colours and this brand of eyeliners have totally changed my outlook on liners! I've tried pots n pencils!this will not budge! Stays put! Colour true! Lasts the entire day! Comes off with yes remover applied to a cotton pad! Looks amazing smudged or in a line! The tin comes with black, navy, gunmetal grey, emerald green and brown liners! On top of this I've purchased tetra which is a purple colour separately! This range in at tin for 5 liners of this quality is a steal! Got mine for R375 n plan to get another set with some ruby rands as my navy liner is almost finished

I have these is both Stingray (purchased as a stand alone) as well as Tetra (which came with my In The Know eyeshadow palette).

These Smudge sticks are the wind up version of the Stila Smudge pots. I find the formula to be very very soft, so therefore I have to be extra careful and apply with a light hand as to not use too much product and make it last a bit longer time wise.

Because the formula is so soft, I find that it glides on very easily and hassle free. The colors are highly pigmented so gives of a rich, intense and vibrant color. It truly is very long lasting and stays literally all day (more so than my usual liners - Avon glimmer stick and Revlon Colorstay Eyliner ) But for the price of R200 and the formula being so soft, I probably wont repurchase as a stand alone product, but definitely more worth it when purchasing an eyeshadow palette and line duo.