Do yourself a favour and get the ever faithful Rimmel eye liner is absolutely any one of the 5 shades it comes in. My black Rimmel Soft Kohl Kajal Eye Pencil is my 'don't leave home without it' item! If you are into the smokey eye effect then this is the pencil that will make it work for you and don't be afraid, the soft tip ensures that you won't accidentally poke your eye out! All in all a top quality eye liner for a pretty good price.