Okay, other than the affordable price tag and the easy application with the super-fine pen tip which gives it a thumbs up, I don't like the fact that this eyeliner fades and also dries out quickly.

I bought a brand new pen (took one from the very back of the stock), took it home, applied it to my lash line, and had to go over the same line about three times to get the colour and definition I wanted. I only used it four times and it started drying out (cap was on tightly). I bought another thinking maybe I had previously bought a dud or one that had been opened before purchase, and the same thing happened.

Even though it's affordable and applies easily, it doesn't meet the mark when it comes to quality and effectiveness.

The problem I have with most of these eyeliner pens are that they just don't last! And I've tried about 9 different once. The pen itself is super fine and application is a breeze and easy for about only the first 3 times after that it fades. What I almost always end up doing is then taking that pen and dipping it into a liquid eyeliner bottle and then doing my liner since the applicator works like a charm.

I think this is definitely one product where the product inside have let down the package or applicator outside. So that said if they could get the liquid to last longer this product would surely be one of my go to products

Winx

Everyone loves a liquid eyeliner but they are difficult to master. This product made it really easy for me. The felt tip makes it so much easier to get it exactly where you want it without messing it up and having to give it several attempts. You basically just draw it where you need it like you would use a marker. The staying power is good and pigmentation is great.

A few draw backs on the product: It started drying out too soon for my liking. It never really went completely dry but that super wet and intense feel when new faded too quickly and it became harder to work with. The pigmentation also started to fade so I had to do a few coats to get the same impact as when new but it removes the coat beneath when you try and layer it.

I would recommend this product to someone who is just starting to make use of liquid eyeliners and rocking cat eyes. It makes it so much easier but use it up in a month or maybe 2. Don't keep it for longer. It will fade.

I love Rimmel's other products, but this liner is not good. It's too light. You can't even build on it to make it darker, because if you try applying a second coat, it erases the first coat. It's easy to apply, I just wish they would improve the pigmentation.