Absolutely love this eyeliner , it doesn't smudge and make me look like a raccoon half way through the day .
The liner is smooth so it doesn't hurt when applying even if your eye tends to water a bit it still glides on perfectly .
The color is intense and long lasting and really good value for money .

Revlon ColorStay Eyeliner Pencil in Black for richer, more intense colour that wears up to 16 Hours.

Packaging:
The eyeliner comes in a 13cm long, black pen holder that is very pen material like than pencil material. The liner is very thin crayon Contour and is about 3.5 cm long when you wind it out. Unlike most pencil eyeliners this one winds up therefore there is no need to sharpen it. But there is a sharpener at the end of the eyeliner which is a pull out sharpener that is white in colour. The text on the eyeliner is white and clear enough to be read.

Benefits:
*It has a smooth very texture allowing for smooth, easy application.
*It stays on for long hours.
*It is waterproof.
*Ophthalmologist Tested

Tips:
-Advance tip to desired length by twisting body of pencil.
-Apply along lash line starting from inner corner of eye working outwards.
-For a fuller look apply a double line as the liner is thinner than usual.

I love that this eye liner is really smooth and that you don't need to press hard to apply it. Mine came in a package deal with the Revlon Lash Potion Mascara for R150, so a really good deal. It also comes with a sharpener on the end.

I love this product, I does justice and it actually works! I have been using this for years and I have yet to find a product in the same price range that works the same or even better than this stick.
It does not smudge, water proof,super black so you don't need to reapply and its long wearing, it does not crack after a few hours of wearing unlike the Avon Glimmer Stick.
The only pet peeve I have is having to take off the product, you need a proper eye make remover to get it off without it leaving your entire eye black. for me that's a small thing and I will carry on using this eye liner for many moons to come.

I would recommend:
MAC eye makeup remover
Gatineau Eye makeup remover
which for me works really well to remove any eye liners that wont budge

This is a great product !! love it !used it for years and had no problems.

I love this and will not change brands anywhere in the near future.

A good quality eyeliner that stays put whole day, does not smudge or run which is a huge heavens scent to any woman! I purchased mine for R139 at Foschini which is really pricey for an eyeliner. Its actually lasting rather long though, so I think good value for money in that respect. It glides on easily to the lids and is high pigmented, so its a really deep intense black which I like. I alternate this with my Essence wind up eye liner which cost only R20, so this comes out when I go for full on make up :)

This eyeliner is simply amazing! I got it as a part of a deal where I bought mascara and this came free. It is so great! It lines effortlessly and clean, crisp lines and is properly black. Also, it does not smudge or run on its own accord. It lasts for hours, and looks amazing. The lines are nice and crisp, too. I would highly recommend this!

My mother gifted me this eyeliner. She was and is a Revlon devotee. For a eyeliner this one is a bit of splurge.. but believe me a good one. I had this for over a year and love it every time I use it. Its just perfect to line your waterline.On me it stays intact for over 8 hours. I also use it as base to create a light smokey eye. You would however need eye makeup remover(in my case I just use plain coconut or olive oil ;-)) to remove it completely.

Highly recommend it!!!!

Presenting my favourite Revlon Colourstay Eyeliner in Black. It's actually traditional for Indian girls to wear eyeliner (we make our own, but it's too long and a little messy to carry around with me, so I purchase one to keep in my bag for touch ups) but this eyeliner is so amazing, I just choose to use it everyday for a perfect look.

This eyeliner is slim and has a sleek, smooth and glossy casing with a retractable eye Khôl or Kajal. People generally say that the retractable eye pencils break, or they finish faster, however that's not true because mine has been lasting me quite some time and it's really amazing. This eyeliner has a creamy consistency which applies perfectly to eyes giving them a well defined look. The pitch black pigments transfer smoothly onto eyes without irritating or burning eyes. I've also noticed that this is the longest eye liner I've ever used and I hardly needed to touch up at all.

PRO's and CON's

PRO's
Super smooth eyeliner
Glides on effortlessly
Has dark pigments
Is available in four shades
The eyeliner is water proof
The eyeliner is fade proof
The eyeliner is smudge proof
Plus it can wear up to 16 hours
The eyeliner is also long lasting
The eyeliner has a strong casing
The eyeliner doesn't need sharpening
The eyeliner doesn't trouble eyes

CON's
The eyeliner is expensive

I would really recommend you give this eyeliner a try, for R130 just for an eyeliner is quite a spurge, however it's smudge proof, waterproof, and fade proof and give eyes an amazing, well defined look without any serious effort. Plus how can you say no to dramatic eyes this winter?

Longest lasting eyeliner I've tried. It is abit expensive for the amount you're getting, but the product is very long lasting because I don't need to reapply eye liner the entire day. Plus the eyeliner doesn't smudge or fade. I'm also impressed with this product because it doesn't hurt or burn sensitive eyes and its perfect for contact lens users.

I think it will be accurate enough to say that this is my "Holy Grail" product since I use it EVERYDAY!! It was recommended to me by a makeup artist about 3 years ago, and I have since never looked at another eyeliner. Because I wear contact lenses, I struggled to find an eyeliner that wouldn't irritate my eyes, and smudge during the day. Revlon Colorstay is the only eyeliner I can use on my waterline without it irritating my eyes, and without being left with giant panda eyes during the day.Even though it's not a waterproof eyeliner you can still trust that it will not smudge or budge.

I have used the black and brown ones and both has never let me down.

This can be purchased at Dischem for about R120.

This is the best eye liner by Revlon. Once applied, it stays on and on and on.....amazing!!! Does not smudge even when applied directly on the waterline. Applies smooth with no tugging. The price is a bit on the high side for a piece, but it lasts really long. l love the idea of build in sharpener, as it avoids product wastage.

Love it...

This shade was perfect for me. I have naturally dark features and really black eyebrows so using a black pencil can sometimes be too much. This shade is a beautiful dark brown and it gave me the definition without adding too much drama that I don't need for work. It looks great with all my bronzy eye shadows that I tend to gravitate towards so much. It lasts amazingly long and literally doesnt budge until you remove it with a makeup remover (and a strong one for that matter).

Having said all the good stuff, I think I might have got old one or something. It feels very dry and tugs on my lids a bit. I just wish it was a bit creamier. Also the pencil broke off somehow from the base so I had to reattach it. I am not completely happy with it for the price I paid even though in general it is not a bad product.

LOVE LOVE LOVE IT!

Easy to use/manage....Wont rub off easily, wont smudge and love the softness in it..easy to remove as well..It lasts long and its R130.00 @ Foschini’s..Got get it

Revlon Colorstay eyeliner is so easy to apply as it just glides on with no mess, no breaking and definately no need for resharpening. Once applied, it can be smudged for a great smokey eye effect, although I found it a bit difficult to smudge as apposed to normal kohl liners. Lasts really long...My liner was stayed put after a long night on the town and was still there, no smudges, in the morning when I woke up!

This is a definate MUST HAVE for the make-up bag and will definately not disappoint!

Great black eyeliner that lasts all day. The formula of the liner is not too creamy, hence it doesn't "slip" off or smudge during the day. Love to use it for tight lining and even outlining the eye. I would say that if you looking to do smudged out liner looks, rather not use the Revlon Colorstay eyeliner. It doesn't smudge that easily (its for longwear).

Smooth easy to aplly and last all day.

This is an awesome eyeliner, it's great for smokey eyes as it's easily blended/smudged and really stays put. The only thing i have a problem with is that whenever i use this liner, my eyes get itchy - other brands don't seem to bother my eyes so much. I've also never had to use the sharpener, so can't comment on that aspect of the liner either. It's so easy to apply and gives you a nice, clean line (steady hands here girls).

Highly effective product!