I have been using this liner for a couple years now and dont feel the need to find a new brand. It does everything that it should, it is super black, glides on easily without smudging and it lasts me a couple of months, so for the price you cant argue with that. I must say that it doesnt last nearly as long as it says it does (12 hours). I will put it on before I go out at night and by the end of the night its gone. Maybe my eyes are just watery but it still wont stop me form using it.