I recieved this eyeliner in my Ruby box. I love the softness of the 'pencil' itself. However..... It took me 2 days to completely take the eyeliner off. I used makeup remover, face wash and the next morning when I awoke, my eyes were black every where. So yes, I'd say this is cool for creating a smokey eye, or even fine lines... But getting it off is a definite mission.