Top Liner has never been my thing, I don't have a steady hand, and always leave the line going all over the place. A friend suggested I try the Maybelline Gel Liner, which I did. And I've never gone wrong since that day! it comes with the cutest little brush for foolproof eye liner and stays for 24 hours! which is a product made in heaven for me because I tend to rub my eyelids now and then. It also has a slight shimmer, which I find great for parties or evenings out! I think everyone should give this product a try!