I loved the cream eye make up remover and I was convinced that this one is almost 10 times better, trust me that was a big ALMOST! It doesn't do anything. It's completely useless. Doesn't help remove make up at all. It has two layers one water based and one oil based, and needs to be shaken to mix the two layers together, once on a cotton wool, the make up remover breaks down the make up but leaves traces all over my face. It also leaves a greesy feeling which I don't really like. I wouldn't recommend this product to anyone. Really.