I was excited to try this eyeliner as i always am about any beauty product i buy.
I tried it out and it went on smoothly.

My problem came when i needed to 'sharpen' the eyeliner after a couple of uses. It has a plastic tube that says 'sharpenable' on it. But i tried to sharpen it with a sharpener...an eyeliner sharpener from an old eyeliner AND a pencil sharpener as well...both of the sharpeners broke :-(

So, I'm now stuck with a full eyeliner that i can't access because I can't sharpen off the plastic around the eyeliner

Because of this, I declare this eyeliner a complete FAIL!