I bought these because they are alcohol free, remove waterproof makeup and are soft thick and the price was good!i dont usually buy these cos the sticky becomes less and then the wipes dry out so there's pressure to use them fast! I usually purchase the ones with a lid irrespective of their price simply cos i use stay fast and transfer resistant long wearing formulas and prefer a wipe to get my make up off nicely the first time!these claim to be made with a gentle caring formulation but my eye area stung terribly and my lids even looked a little swollen! I haven't been able to continue with these!