I'll be honest, I was quite disappointed when I bought this eyeliner. I was never a huge liquid khoki eyeliner fan but I decided to put that behind me and try it.

If you have eye shadow on, you don't get a clear line, you get a faded gray smudged line. Thats not good if you are looking for the darker smokey eye effect. also once you do eventually get a nice clear black line it only last for about two hours and its faded again.

Only after using it on a few occasions did it start working nicely and the line became clearer on the eye and lasting longer.

It isn't a completely terrible product, but its could be improved.