I recently purchased the Waterproof version of the Essence Get BIG! Lashes Mascara as my usual purple packaged one was out of stock.

I figured it would have the same effect but I was slightly disappointed. Yes my lashes looked darker but they definitely didn't look as full or as "bold"

Also, i'm not really a fan of waterproof mascaras in general because I find that my lashes fall out when I wash my make-up off at the end of the day. (maybe its just me)

I'm still a die hard fan of the Essence Get BIG! Lashes Mascara but will stay clear of the waterproof version!