I always buy the Waterproof version of mascara's as I've heard they hold a curl better. I bought this to layer under my Holy Grail lengthening mascara for added volume and never expected much from it as I was never going to use it on its own-but boy did this mascara surprise me.

It does not clump and the brush combs through my lashes nicely. It adds volume and makes my eyes look large and doe-like. Admittedly my curl has fallen after a full night out with friends which includes dinner, a movie (or two) and general messing about, but all this does is have me go from a clean doe-eyed look, to a lived in cat-eyed look, which isn't bad at all.