I have not used the one in the pot, but I currently use the one in the tube and I love it! I actually like it more than my Mac Paint Pot and my Mac Paint.

It is very creamy and applies like a dream. It does not set completely dry, but remains a little tacky. I usually set it with a little translucent powder.

It definitely enhances your eyeshadow colours and helps them last all day and I mean all day long. This stuff does not move unless you take it off. I always get complimented on my eyeshadow whenever I use this. I asolutely recommend this!