I've struggled with finding a bright colours that look the same way on my eye as it does on the pencil and I haven't found many that have met my criteria.
This eye pencil is soft yet still firm enough to hold a precise line. The colour is gorgeously bright and vibrant whether I apply it to the waterline or the lashline. I've yet to test out the waterproof abilities but it does not fade through the day and comes off easily with a cotton bud and a good makeup remover.
All in all, it's exactly what I was looking for and it brings out my brown eyes perfectly. A good pop of colour is just what I need when the weather is cool and grey.