I really like the formula of this mascara. I could tell from applying this mascara for the first time, that the formula is great quality! What disappointed me (i had high expectations) was the clumping. This mascara clumps so easily. My sister was also complaining about it. But in conclusion, its just a good quality product with a few flaws. I dont think i would repurchase it, especially with the amazing variety of mascaras out.