I'll be honest, it is a fantastic product, it is long lasting and has that mascara effect. But, I'm more one of those people who like the bold, thick mascara effect that gives volume. This product is great for if you want the length in, gentle effect. It also works great as a base mascara, If you apply it first and then a voluminous mascara over it, you are granted a long last hold. So it has its perks and it's flaws. But all in all a very good product.