I buy this whenever it is on special and it is quite impressive in that it delivers what it promises. The color is richly pigmented and once applied it stays put , no smudging at all. I took a shower with this eye liner on and when I got out it was still in place!! This time I got mine in the shades "starry night blue" and " Smokey grey".. The blue is so rich,bold and vibrant in color and really stands out, the grey is subtle and I apply it thicky on my lower lashline as well .. I'm really loving these Avon winners ;)