These are my go-to, HG (holy grail) eye liners

And whilst they are a bit pricey, they are often on special and you can get them at a really good price.

I find that they are quite pigmented and really long lasting and best of all, they dont smudge! (Avon claims they are waterproof but I haven't tested the theory)
I don't have to keep checking in the mirror if I look like a panda bear Lol!

I use them on a daily basis. Sometimes just to line my upper and lower water line and sometimes I line my upper lash line as well.

I really love the packaging.
It's so elegant. I personally don't like pencil eyeliners because you have to keep sharpening them! Not to mention, that I've been poked in the eye, a few times, by a tiny piece of wood sticking out!

The only downfall is the price, normal price is R89.95 each. But, as I mentioned, they often go on special, like this month. They have a buy 1, get 2 free. So obviously, I stocked up! :D