I have this eyeliner in black and I really love this eyeliner, the best part is that it comes with a smudger which makes a smokey eye look much easier to achieve! To use the product as an eyeliner is the best idea ever though, because the colour is really long lasting and doesn't fate quickly, the colour is also a dark deep black which doesn't smudge or get easily removed from eyes, so it's perfect if you love wearing eyeliner for a longer period of time.